Skip to content

BLACK FRIDAY: UP TO 29% OFF + FREE HERPILIP ON ORDERS $70+ · AUTO-APPLIED AT CHECKOUT

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel vs BioVelvet

May 31, 202616 min read

Mederma vs BioVelvet compared

Two different bets on scar recovery.

A pharmacy-stocked overnight scar specialist against a multi-indication recovery cream built around a New Zealand deer antler velvet story. Here is how the price, the timeline, and the ingredient list actually compare.

Shop BioVelvet →

How the Mederma scar gel and BioVelvet compare

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is a once-daily gel made to soften the look of a single scar, and BioVelvet Recovery Cream is a recovery cream for dry, tight or irritated skin, including the skin around a healed scar. Mederma also sells an overnight version, Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream, so this guide covers both Mederma products next to BioVelvet.

The two brands take different routes. Mederma builds its formulas around Cepalin, its onion bulb extract, and a scar timeline measured in months. BioVelvet builds its cream around deer antler velvet extract with glycerin, sodium hyaluronate, allantoin and bisabolol, and it is meant for daily comfort on skin that feels fragile.

Price is the first thing most people notice. Mederma Advanced Scar Gel costs $16.47 for 0.7 oz (20 g) at Walmart, and Mederma PM costs $18.88 for 1 oz (28 g) there. BioVelvet Recovery Cream is $64.90 for a 50 ml bottle, $54.87 on a monthly subscription, and every order carries a 90-day money-back guarantee from the brand. We checked every price in this comparison on November 9, 2026, ours on our own store and each of the others at the retailer named beside it.

Quick picks by need

If you want Pick
🌿 Comfort for dry or irritated skin around a healed scar BioVelvet Recovery Cream
🎯 A low-cost daily gel for one flat scar Mederma Advanced Scar Gel
🌙 One scar step at night Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream
🩹 Care for a raised or fresh surgical scar Silicone gel or sheets first, with a cream alongside

Who this comparison is for

This guide is for someone with a specific scar, from acne, surgery, a minor burn or an injury, who is weighing a pharmacy scar gel against a recovery cream. Maybe you have already decided to do something about the scar and want the right format, the right ingredients and a sensible budget. Or the scar is only part of it, and the skin around it is dry, tight or easily irritated too.

Either way, the choice gets easier once you know what each product was built to do. The sections below compare price, sizes, returns and formulas, then match each product to the reader it suits.

BioVelvet Recovery Cream 50 ml bottle
Scar area comfortComfort for the skin around your scar, beside Mederma or siliconeGlycerin and sodium hyaluronate draw in water, while allantoin and bisabolol calm tight, irritated skin.$54.87 subscribed or $64.90 onceSee the cream90-day money-back guarantee. Patch test first: contains tea tree oil and royal jelly (bee-derived).

The three products at a glance

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is the brand’s everyday scar product. You apply it once a day to clean, dry skin once a wound has closed, and Mederma asks for at least 8 weeks on new scars and 3 to 6 months on existing ones. The brand page lists the full ingredients: allantoin, onion bulb extract, panthenol and sodium hyaluronate in a water and alcohol gel base, with fragrance. It comes in 0.7 oz (20 g) and 1.76 oz (50 g) tubes and sits in nearly every US pharmacy.

Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream is the night version. It pairs Cepalin botanical extract with Tripeptol, which Mederma describes as a complex of peptides, collagen and antioxidants, in a non-greasy cream made for once-nightly use. It comes in a 1.0 oz (28 g) tube and a 1.7 oz (48 g) jar. Mederma says it is the scar brand U.S. physicians and pharmacists recommend most, based on a survey by an independent market research firm.

The third product here is BioVelvet Recovery Cream, a petroleum-free, lanolin-free and silicone-free cream from a direct-to-consumer brand. Its hero ingredient is New Zealand deer antler velvet extract, sourced from farmed deer and harvested before the antler hardens. Lab and animal research on velvet looks at the compounds behind antler regrowth, and our explainer on growth factors in skincare covers how that research is read. The cream also contains aloe vera, jojoba seed oil, Dead Sea minerals and ginkgo biloba, and it is made for skin that feels dry or irritated, from eczema-prone patches to the skin around a closed scar. Patch test first: contains tea tree oil and royal jelly (bee-derived).

What sets each product apart

Category BioVelvet Recovery CreamBioVelvet Recovery Cream Mederma Advanced Scar GelMederma Advanced Scar Gel Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar CreamMederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream
Format Cream in a 50 ml bottle Gel in a tube Cream in a tube or jar
When to use Day or night, two to three times a day Once a day Once a day, at night
Made for Dry, tight or irritated skin, including the skin around a closed scar The look of acne, surgery, burn and injury scars The look of acne, surgery, burn and injury scars
Key ingredients Deer antler velvet extract, glycerin, sodium hyaluronate, allantoin, bisabolol, aloe vera, jojoba seed oil Allantoin, onion bulb extract (Cepalin), panthenol, sodium hyaluronate Cepalin botanical extract, Tripeptol
Brand timeline Use daily and judge it within the 90-day guarantee At least 8 weeks on new scars, 3 to 6 months on existing scars At least 8 weeks on new scars, 3 to 6 months on existing scars
Guarantee or returns 90-day money-back guarantee from the brand Set by the retailer Set by the retailer
Animal-derived Deer antler velvet and royal jelly (bee-derived) Not stated Not stated
Where to buy BioVelvet’s own store (US and UK) CVS, Rite Aid, Target, Walgreens, Walmart, Amazon CVS, Rite Aid, Target, Walgreens, Walmart, Amazon

Cost sizes returns and formula compared

The overview above is the quick read. The next tables cover what you pay, which sizes exist, how buying and returns work, and what each brand puts on the label.

What you pay

Product Size One-time price Subscription
BioVelvet Recovery Cream 50 ml (1.7 fl oz) $64.90 $54.87 a month, or two bottles for $99.91 every 2 months
Mederma Advanced Scar Gel 0.7 oz (20 g) $16.47 at Walmart Retail purchase only
Mederma Advanced Scar Gel 1.76 oz (50 g) $35.81 at Walmart Retail purchase only
Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream 1.0 oz (28 g) $18.88 at Walmart Retail purchase only
Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream 1.7 oz (48 g) $24.56 at Walmart Retail purchase only

Prices checked November 9, 2026.

Mederma is the lower-cost tube, and a pharmacy price makes it an easy first try for one small scar. BioVelvet Recovery Cream costs more per bottle, and that price buys a cream you can use on the scar area and on any other dry, irritated patch, plus 90 days to ask for your money back if you change your mind.

Sizes each brand sells

Mederma sells real size options. The gel comes in a 0.7 oz tube for a single small scar and a 1.76 oz tube for a larger area, and the PM cream comes in a 1.0 oz tube or a 1.7 oz jar. BioVelvet sells one 50 ml bottle, with a single-bottle plan and a two-bottle plan rather than bigger sizes. The closest like-for-like match is the 1.76 oz (50 g) Mederma gel at $35.81 against the 50 ml BioVelvet bottle at $64.90.

How you buy it and how returns work

Product Where you buy it Shipping Returns
BioVelvet Recovery Cream BioVelvet’s own store, US and UK Free on subscriptions, free on one-time orders above $99.90 90-day money-back guarantee from the brand
Mederma Advanced Scar Gel and Mederma PM CVS, Rite Aid, Target, Walgreens, Walmart and Amazon, in store or online Set by the retailer, with in-store pickup at most pharmacy chains Set by the retailer, for example free 90-day returns at Walmart

Mederma is the one you can pick up at a pharmacy and use the same evening. BioVelvet ships to your door, and its guarantee comes from the brand itself, so the terms stay the same however you order.

What each brand puts on the label

Product Ingredient list Hero ingredients Scent Animal-derived
BioVelvet Recovery Cream Full INCI on the carton Deer antler velvet extract with glycerin, sodium hyaluronate, allantoin and bisabolol No added parfum; tea tree and manuka are aromatic botanicals Deer antler velvet and royal jelly (bee-derived)
Mederma Advanced Scar Gel Full list on the brand page Allantoin and onion bulb extract (Cepalin) Contains fragrance Not stated
Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream Key ingredients on the brand page Cepalin botanical extract and Tripeptol (peptides, collagen and antioxidants, per Mederma) Not listed on the brand page Not stated

Mederma describes both formulas as a triple-action approach to the look of scars. BioVelvet leads with comfort and hydration: glycerin and sodium hyaluronate draw water into dry skin, allantoin smooths rough patches, and bisabolol calms the look of redness. For each BioVelvet ingredient in plain words, see the BioVelvet ingredients guide.

How to decide between a scar gel and a recovery cream

These products are built for different jobs. Mederma’s gel and night cream aim at the look of one scar over 8 weeks to several months. BioVelvet Recovery Cream is a daily comfort cream for stressed, uncomfortable skin, and the skin around a healed scar is one of the places it does that job well. So the better choice depends on what is going on across your skin, and on how many products you want in the routine.

If this sounds like you Lean toward Why
🧴 A scar plus dry, tight or irritated skin around it BioVelvet Recovery Cream One cream covers the scar area and the dry patches nearby, day or night
🎯 One flat scar and nothing else Mederma Advanced Scar Gel A once-daily gel with a timeline that follows how scars mature
🌙 You only want a night step Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream Made for one application each evening
🩹 A raised or fresh surgical scar Silicone gel or sheets The usual first step for raised scars, with either cream alongside
💊 An active acne treatment plan Ask your clinician first Mederma asks you to finish the acne regimen before you start

Silicone stays the first step for raised and new surgical scars, and both creams fit around it. That order matches the 2002 international scar management recommendations by Mustoe and colleagues in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, which give silicone gel sheeting a primary role for raised scars and keloids. Our guide to silicone scar sheets explains how to choose a sheet for each body area. For the science background on the BioVelvet hero ingredient, see what deer antler velvet research covers.

Which one to choose and when

BioVelvet Recovery Cream
Best for comfort around the scar

BioVelvet Recovery Cream

$54.87 subscribed or $64.90 once, 50 ml

BioVelvet Recovery Cream suits people whose scar is only part of the story: the skin around it feels dry or tight, a procedure has left the area irritated, or eczema-prone patches need care at the same time. Glycerin and sodium hyaluronate hydrate, allantoin and bisabolol bring comfort, and the cream is built around New Zealand deer antler velvet extract in a petroleum-free, lanolin-free and silicone-free base.

It goes on day or night, two to three times a day, and it works alongside silicone or a scar gel. Every order has a 90-day money-back guarantee. Patch test first: contains tea tree oil and royal jelly (bee-derived).

Shop now90-day money-back guarantee

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel
Best for a once-daily scar gel

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel

$16.47 for 0.7 oz (20 g) at Walmart

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is the pharmacy staple for the look of acne, surgery, burn and injury scars. It pairs allantoin with Cepalin onion bulb extract in a light gel that you apply once a day, starting once the wound has closed.

Mederma asks for at least 8 weeks on new scars and 3 to 6 months on older ones. The 0.7 oz tube suits a single small scar, and the 1.76 oz tube ($35.81 at Walmart) is better value for a larger area.

Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream
Best for a night-only routine

Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream

$18.88 for 1 oz (28 g) at Walmart

Mederma PM is the brand’s overnight scar cream, made to be applied once each night. It combines Cepalin botanical extract with Tripeptol, a complex Mederma describes as peptides, collagen and antioxidants, in a non-greasy texture that suits a bedtime routine.

Like the gel, it follows an 8-week timeline for new scars and 3 to 6 months for existing ones. Mederma notes it is for scars only and asks you to pause it during an acne treatment regimen. The 1.7 oz jar costs $24.56 at Walmart.

How they compare on the details that matter

Routine fit

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel goes on once a day, and Mederma PM once at night. BioVelvet Recovery Cream can be applied morning and evening, or two to three times a day on the driest areas. If you like a single scar product plus a separate moisturizer, Mederma slots in easily. If you would rather use one cream through the day, BioVelvet fits that routine.

What each product is made for

Both Mederma products focus on scars from acne, burns, injury and surgery, and that narrow focus is a strength when one scar is all you are dealing with. Mederma’s gel page shows it on acne scars and on small scars around the ears after cosmetic surgery, so it works on the face as well. BioVelvet Recovery Cream covers dry, tight and irritated skin more broadly, so the same bottle can look after the scar area, eczema-prone patches and skin that feels stressed after a procedure.

How long each one takes

Mederma’s timeline is at least 8 weeks on new scars and 3 to 6 months on existing scars, which matches how slowly scar tissue changes. Take a photo in the same light every two weeks, because side-by-side photos show slow scar changes far better than a mirror does. BioVelvet Recovery Cream works on how the skin feels, so the change you notice first is softer, more comfortable skin around the scar, with daily use over weeks for the best result.

Professional recommendation

Mederma says it is the scar brand most recommended by U.S. physicians and pharmacists, based on a survey run by an independent market research firm. If your pharmacist’s advice weighs heavily for you, that matters. BioVelvet brings a different kind of reassurance: a formula developed by a veterinary scientist who has spent more than 20 years with deer antler velvet, and a 90-day money-back guarantee.

Trial and returns

Mederma returns go through the store you bought from, so the window depends on that retailer. Walmart lists free 90-day returns on both Mederma products. BioVelvet’s 90-day money-back guarantee comes from the brand, which gives you a full three months to judge the cream on your own skin.

Using them with other products

Mederma’s FAQ asks you to wait until an acne treatment regimen, such as benzoyl peroxide, is finished before starting Mederma, and to apply it only to acne scars. When you are mixing several actives, the safest move is to check the plan with your clinician.

Animal ingredients in each formula

Mederma does not publish an animal-derived statement on its product pages, so its vegan status is unclear. BioVelvet Recovery Cream contains deer antler velvet from New Zealand farms, harvested before the antler hardens, and royal jelly, so it suits people who are comfortable with animal-derived ingredients.

BioVelvet vs Mederma at a glance

BioVelvet

  • Comfort for the scar area and dry, irritated skin
  • Day or night, two to three times a day
  • 90-day money-back guarantee
  • Petroleum-free and lanolin-free

Mederma

  • Most recommended scar brand in its survey of U.S. doctors
  • Lower price per tube
  • Scar-focused, once a day
  • Pause during an acne treatment regimen

Bottom line: Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is a low-cost, once-daily gel for the look of a single scar. BioVelvet Recovery Cream brings day-or-night comfort to the scar area and the dry skin around it, with a 90-day money-back guarantee.

How to use Mederma and BioVelvet for the best result

Both Mederma products start once the wound has fully closed and any stitches or scabs are gone. Apply a thin layer of the gel to clean, dry skin once a day, or the PM cream once each night, and massage it in gently until it disappears. Mederma ties its timeline to steady daily use, so a missed week sets the clock back more than a missed day.

BioVelvet Recovery Cream follows the directions on its carton: clean and dry the area, then apply two to three times a day wherever the skin feels dry or tight. Use it on intact skin, and start with a small patch for a couple of days if your skin reacts easily. The light texture absorbs without a greasy film, so it layers easily under clothing or other products.

Whichever product you choose, daily sunscreen on a scar that sees daylight helps it settle to a color closer to the skin around it. Sun on a healing scar can keep it darker for longer, so this step matters most while the scar is still pink or red. In a 2007 randomised trial in Acta Dermato-Venereologica, Due and colleagues exposed some of the small test wounds on 14 healthy volunteers to solar UV after surgery, and the scars that healed open were rated more disfiguring at 12 weeks, with more pigment than scars kept out of the light.

Using both in one routine

You can give each product its own job. Apply Mederma Advanced Scar Gel to the scar line once a day, or Mederma PM at night, and use BioVelvet Recovery Cream at other times of day on the dry or tight skin around it. Let each layer absorb before the next one goes on. The same pattern works with silicone gel or sheets: silicone stays on the scar, and the cream looks after the skin around it and the hours the sheet is off. If the scar is recent or came from surgery, ask your surgeon before you add anything new.

What to expect from either product

Mederma and BioVelvet both improve how skin looks and feels over time, and both work best as part of a routine that includes daily sunscreen on scars that see daylight. For a wider look at surgical scar cream options across formats and price points, our category guide covers the field. For minor burns, the best burn cream overview explains which products suit each stage of a burn.

Hold each product to the job it was made for and the results make sense. A scar gel works slowly on the look of a scar, and a recovery cream keeps the surrounding skin comfortable while that happens.

When to see a doctor about a scar

Some scars need a clinician rather than another product. See a dermatologist or your surgeon if a scar keeps growing past the original wound, becomes raised, hard, painful or very itchy, or tightens enough to limit movement, because keloid and hypertrophic scars respond best to medical treatment such as steroid injections, pressure therapy or laser. Get help straight away for signs of infection, a wound that has not closed, or a serious burn.

A simple way to choose

If you have one flat scar and nothing else, Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is a low-cost, once-daily choice, and Mederma PM suits you if you only want a night step. If the scar comes with dry or irritated skin nearby, or you want one cream for several concerns, BioVelvet Recovery Cream is the better fit, and its guarantee makes the first bottle an easy trial.

Two BioVelvet Recovery Cream 50 ml bottles
Scar area comfortDaily comfort for the skin around your scar, alongside MedermaUse it day or night on dry, irritated skin, with a 90-day money-back guarantee. 90-day money-back guarantee. Cancel anytime.

FAQ

Can I use Mederma PM during the day too?

Mederma made PM for once-a-day use at night, and its own FAQ says the night cream is for people who prefer that single evening step. For a daytime scar product, Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is the brand’s once-daily option.

BioVelvet Recovery Cream goes on morning or night, two to three times a day, so it can cover the daytime hours while a night scar cream does its work.

How long do Mederma and BioVelvet take to show results?

Mederma asks for at least 8 weeks of daily use on new scars and 3 to 6 months on existing scars, because a scar’s look changes slowly as it matures.

BioVelvet Recovery Cream works on how the skin feels. Glycerin and sodium hyaluronate draw water into dry skin from the first applications, and allantoin and bisabolol bring comfort to tight, irritated patches. Three months of money-back cover gives you time to judge it on your own skin.

Which one should I buy for a specific surgical scar?

Start with what your surgeon recommends, which for a fresh, closed surgical scar is usually silicone gel or sheets. Mederma Advanced Scar Gel is a once-daily option for the look of the scar, used once the wound has fully closed.

BioVelvet Recovery Cream suits the skin around the incision once it starts to feel dry and tight, and it works alongside silicone. Our best scar cream guide compares the main options across pharmacy and online brands.

Can I use BioVelvet Recovery Cream on more than one skin concern?

Yes. BioVelvet Recovery Cream is made for dry, tight or irritated skin, which covers the skin around a healed scar, eczema-prone patches and skin that feels stressed after a procedure. Clean and dry the area, then apply two to three times a day on intact skin.

Patch test first: contains tea tree oil and royal jelly (bee-derived).

I am on a benzoyl peroxide regimen for acne. Can I still use Mederma PM on my acne scars?

Mederma’s FAQ answers this directly: wait until the acne treatment regimen is finished and the breakouts have settled, then apply Mederma to the acne scars only, never to active acne or open skin.

If you are combining several actives, check the plan with your clinician before you add any new product.

This comparison was written by BioVelvet. Mederma is included for comparison and paid nothing for placement. It is general information, not medical advice. Prices and formulas change, so check the current product page before you buy.